Everything to Everyone
(Reprise)
Release Date: 10/21/2003 12:00
If I check the irony/Would everybody cheer me? Steven Page, singer-guitarist for alt-pop smart-asses Barenaked Ladies, wonders on Testing 123, a cheeky, self-referential jangle-pop jaunt from their sixth album. Despite the question, the album shows that BNL arent quite ready to play it straight. For every earnest, country-inflected love song (For You), theres a nonsensical synth-pop ode to shopping (Shopping). For every time singer-guitarist Ed Robertson injects gravitas into a solemn, swaying song about suicide (War on Drugs), Page yammers a mile-a-minute rhyme about postcards of chimpanzees (Another Postcard [Chimps]) in the mold of their car-commerical hit One Week. They do loosen up the folk-pop shackles, laying strings across four tracks and working up an odd tango/klezmer groove on Upside Down. But the record feels uneven, as the oscillation between frivolous and serious makes both less convincing.