David Archuleta is increasingly looking like the one to beat on Idol this year. Last night, the 17-year-old took on John Lennon’s “Imagine,” and we sat back waiting for the inevitable ruination of a classic. Instead, Archuleta managed to deliver a soccer mom-friendly version that seemed earnest, emotive and alarmingly moving. It’s sort of comical how much better he is than the other nine guys left in the race. David Cook is still the most authentic rocker, Michael Johns the most promising hunky crooner, Chikezie the cheese ball soul singer with the best pipes, but little Archuleta made them all look like frat boys at a karaoke-themed mixer last night. We’re really hoping that Carly or Amanda – one of the girls with a little grit – will deliver a performance to rival Archuleta’s tomorrow night because otherwise we’re going to find ourselves grudgingly rooting for this kid who displays the oppressive cheerfulness of a pageant princess.

David Archuleta: "Imagine"